From our archive · German original first published 8 July 2020. English translation published 26 October 2026. The content reflects the time of the original publication; references to offers, prices, tools and the team may have changed.
Diesen Beitrag auf Deutsch lesen

Almost everyone running a website wants to be number one on Google. That is already the problem: everyone wants it, but only one can occupy the spot. A constant battle for the top search result begins. Then comes “the rescue”: a wizard on horseback, promising to put your website in first place.
Wait, this is not a fairy tale! Or is it?
Let’s start at the beginning with search results.
What makes up the search results?
A search engine results page, or SERP, has many components: advertisements, organic results, shopping ads, images, videos, maps, the Knowledge Graph, answer boxes and news. More features will surely follow.
Let’s look at a SERP for the query “AUDI”.

What is in the image?
- Paid Google advertisements, with the number varying by competition
- The Knowledge Graph: content automatically generated by Google for the query
- The first organic result
- Local search: results near the location of the query
- Google News: news articles about the query
- Organic results in positions two to six
- Google tracking settings
This is just one example from our office computer.
Two factors behind the results
Why does it matter? Two fundamental factors influence search results:
- How well does the website meet Google’s ranking factors?
- Who is searching, when, where and on which device?
We are almost back to our wizard. First, a quick explanation.
Google uses a machine to read websites and assess them using an algorithm. That algorithm is continually adjusted, and more than 200 factors can affect a ranking. The biggest known factors are content, references, technology and user signals. We will explore this further on our website or in a personal conversation.
Every Google user leaves traces. These may be very detailed or broad, but Google knows quite a lot about who you are. Do you use Android on your phone or Chrome as your browser? Then Google very likely knows almost every step you take and your preferences. That means you receive different results from a colleague, for example.
Now we know how many factors and influences affect search results. We are prepared. Time to face the SEO wizard.
Many experts promise strong rankings and can even produce evidence of them.
Wow! How does that work? Often with little tricks
Had you never thought about SEO before, and now a report shows improved rankings following some work?
No wonder, and no magic: factors on your website have been improved, so rankings are very likely to rise.
Have you tried SEO before without much success, but now receive a report showing impressive queries where you are first or in the top ten?
There may be several reasons earlier efforts did not work. But when you receive a report, question the search volume and competition for those keywords. It is not hard for a reasonably skilled wizard to gain rankings where there is little competition or almost no search volume.
A small example: optimising for “purple chocolate praline at Alsterhaus Hamburg” is much easier than optimising for “chocolate Hamburg”. Why? Hardly anyone searches for the long query, so there is almost no competition.
External platforms: useful or not?
Some wizards even offer platforms supposedly designed to deliver success. What happens there? They may create business profiles and optimise pages for your queries, sometimes adding links to your website.
Does that make sense? Yes and no.
Your first goal should be to optimise your own presence before using external platforms. You would rather have customers on your own site than spend your money creating a competitor in the results. Once your own presence is strong enough, such a platform can be an additional supporting tool.
Ultimately, recognising dubious magic and questioning results matters. You will probably have to spend some time understanding the subject yourself.
“We have seen plenty of wizards, but with 90% it was more appearance than substance. Be careful.”



